Skip to main content

Week 5 [03.04 - 09.04.2017] Judging people: awful feature or ‘just reality’.

Judging people is a very common thing in everyday life. We do it very often – regardless of the situation or place: at work, school, café, in the shop or even commuting. All the time. Sometimes we eavesdrop and that’s why we have an opinion. Mostly we judge people by their  looks, because it’s the first thing that we perceive,  get to know. There are two sides of judging people.

Firstly, cons. My friend once told me that she didn’t like a girl from the moment she met her. When I asked why, she answered she didn’t know, but probably because of her looks. Probably all of us, at least once, have done the same. We can point out a lot of examples, for instance, a doctor with tattoos is not a reliable person.

Secondly, pros. A well-kept man builds trust or is considered an expert in his field. Often, handsome people are just better perceived.

It can be considered in many, many fields, but I think good looks aren’t everything.

Cameron Russell tries to persuade that good looks aren’t everything. Please watch and tell us if you agree.



Questions:
  1. Do you agree that looks aren’t everything?
  2. Do you judge people? Why? If so, tell us about it.
  3. Do you think judging people (especially based on looks) makes us awful?
  4.  Is your/somebody’s look important for you? Perhaps, it is the most important thing. 

Comments

Unknown said…
Everybody knows that looks isn't everything. Often people who look good in reality have worse personality than people who look worse. I think everybody should care about his body and hygene. It's true that we judge people by the way they look.
I think this is a good idea not to look different because then people remmeber you. I know people who like making a lot of noise around them and be in center of attention. Everyone has different personality.
Unknown said…
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said…
You said often people who look good in reality have worse personality than people who look worse. Really do you think so? Perhaps do you mean people who are sleek? For me, it's not the same as 'they are look good'
Unknown said…
I agree that look is not everything. I think that judging by look is quite natural thing. Personally I would not be afraid of doctor with tatoos, maybe because I've met people being professionalin their respective fields regardless their look. Judging does not makes us awful - it is just impossible to get to know everyone, sometimes you need to start from somewhere. Problem is not judging by looks, but staying with your believes even if your judgements are constatly being proven wrong.
Anonymous said…
I totally agree that looks doesn't matter when it comes to judging. But I see that people usually talk about it in way "hey, he's ugly, but he may be very nice and friendly.", but many people can't see the other side of a problem. There are lots of people who look nice and they're smiling to everyone at the street but they may be very stupid or just rude to others.
I don't judge people basing on their appearance. Maybe because I've met a lot of people who I've find out very polite in spite of their weak look.
Judging people makes us awful. I totally agree and we should everybody stop doing it.
Unknown said…
I believe that at some point everyone judge other people. It's not always negative, but mostly. I try not to judge by looks, because sometime ago I was really fat and ugly and I know that this is hurtful. But I judge people by they behavior, first impression. If someone looks at me frown I think that it is not nice, but when someone greets me with smile I mostly like then instantly.
Do not judge other people, and they will not judge you.
It seems, if you do not judge anyone, nobody will judge you either. But let speak honest, judge others is in human nature. People need to discuss, analyze, recognize others, distinguish between good and evil, and so on. Well, the fact that if you do not judge or condemn anyone, does not guarantee that other people will not judge or condemn you. Of course, often judging others has negative color than positive. In my life, I try to judge people by their actions and behavior, not appearance. In our time, the appearance can be changed as you want. But the fact that some people inside are ugly can not be so easy to fix, which is why, if a person is morally poor, then it isn't important whether he/she is beautiful or not.
Unknown said…
Good point! I agree that there are the other side of a problem. Honestly, I hear sometimes something like 'so what she's beautiful, if she's not kind person'. It's not as often as it should be, but I believe people are changing and try not to judge, because it's often not good way, as you said.
Unknown said…
It's good you said that! Judging people by their behaviour, in my opinion, is less 'ineffective', but what's more important - we have an influence on our behaviour and the way people look at us, while looks not always depends on us.
Unknown said…
I have an impression that everybody says about juding in case somebody is fat or ugly. What about juding well-kept people? Or when somebody smells nice/not? These things depend on a person and his approach to the environment.
When you go to the first date, do you judge only by behaviour? Isn't it important e.g. men would be well-kept and smell nice?
Unknown said…
Good point that people need to gossip. In my opinion, this feature makes we judge.
Unknown said…
Why we judge other people?
1) We are insecure. This is the main reason we judge.
2) We are scared. Often, when we're scared or intimated by other people, we'll put them down.
3) We are lonely. When you are lonely, you might use judgments to bond with other people, but these bonds are based on negativity. The bonds you have based on judging others are superficial and are not likely to contain true substance.
4) We are seeking change. When we want our own lives to be different, we are quick to judge the lives of others.

I think that we should better follow this rules to avoid judging other people:
- look for the positive
- avoid stereotyping
- focus on your own life
- remember how it feels
Unknown said…
I totally agree with your point of view that it's quite natural for people to have an opinion about others based on their look only, so I wouldn't say that unconditioned reflex is bad in itself, but rather not trying to fight with that and unwillingness to change our opinion when we were wrong makes as awful people.
Of course the way you look is not the most important. But when you meet somebody for the first time, it is first thing you notice about that person, it creates the first impression. But truely, people are so much different, you can never be sure who are you dealing with. Looks is only a shell under which is all the person's core. Appearance can be always deceptive!
Unknown said…
Yeah, I agree with you, but don't you think that it's impossible not to judge? We always try to find ourselves in a situation and judging helps us. Regardless of the fact it's positive or not.
Michał Pycek said…
Unfortunately, I think it is natural for people to judge other people. Sometimes somebody looks appealing and trustworthy to us and we feel that this person is similar to us in this way, on the other hand we may find somebody creepy, dishonest, scary or simply not appealing, so we take this person as a totally not in our kind.
I think it is quite natural to do this and we will not be able to avoid it, because it is about the first impression of a person presenting his or her image. The first thing we see influences the first thing we think of this person, so obviously we judge this experience in a positive or negative way.
Unknown said…
In my opinion it's natural that when you meet someone the first thing that you do is judge this person based on appearance and often depends on it that you want to talk to this person. Of course look isn't everything. I have experienced this many times. I didn't always look great I was a thicker and worn a braces and glasses so I wasn't a beauty but it's change and the saddest thing is that many people who ignored me suddenly started to notice me beacuse my appearance changed, maybe I was slimmer, but in fact my character hasn't changed. I don't trust people for whom appearance is most important beacuse it could be change and that's who i'm not. We are all aging and we won't always be beautiful and young so it's more important that what kind of people we are.
Wojtek Kania said…
Yes, I judge people. I think everyone judging people, but nobody doesn't admit. The way how we looks shows other people who we are. For example Steve Jobs always wears sneakers, jeans and black turtleneck. They are not very expensive But he wears New Balance and Levi's. Look this is only American brands. On any Apple products you can see 'Designed in California'. Steve knows that everyone judging people and he wants that everyone knows that Apple and him is really American brand.
Unknown said…
I admit that appearance may cause a wrong judge of a person. Almost always when we meet new people first what we see is how they look like. I agree with you that it isn't everything, but sometimes we are able to find out something about person basing on appearance.
I never judge people. I think that everyone can do whatever they want to and no one can judge them. It doesn't change anything in my opinion. I also hope that anyone is judging me neither.
I think that judging people makes us rude and awful. As I said it doesn't change anything. People do it just to show what is their opinion about someone, but in fact no one cares about it.
In my life look is the last thing I care about. Honestly, I care about hygiene and things like that, but I'm not trying to be the best looking person.
Maciej Główka said…
I think that it is quite normal to judge by the look when you see someone for the first time. However, this shouldn't be our biggest and most important judgement. Behavior and intelligence should be key points. Unfortunately, most people don't think this way and it is really hard to change their way of thinking.
It should be common knowledge that looks isn't everything, and very often it's not a concern. I'm trying hard to not judge people by how they look, especially because I'm not super-handsome either, but sadly it's quite common to make first impression based solely on how given person looks, and very often it might be the only impression you will have to judge on, until much much later when you actually get to know the person better.

That's why it's crucial to look good when you're interacting with many people you don't know very well or at all - e.g. during conferences, simply because people will usually have better opinion about you on their first sight, which might be crucial especially if those are not people you see usually.
Unknown said…
Unfortunately people when see someone for the first time, they evaluate this person some degree after appearance. Later, after the conversation, they change their minds. I personally try not to judge by appearance.
Unknown said…
Totally agree! I also believe that everyone judges but doesn't want to admit. What do you think - why? Is it a shame?
Unknown said…
Do you manage this? I also try to do it, but sometimes I can see that despite I don't want to do this in a moment, I do it subconsciously
Unknown said…
I'm trying not to judge people at all. Not by their look, behavior, race, nationality, skin color, taste in music or movies and so on. When I say that I try to do this, I mean that it's my active activity. I think, it in our blood to judge others and to gossip, but when I catch myself doing this, I try to stop it. There is nothing good in judging people, nothing that can bring something useful in our lives. Judging brings only negativity and concentration on something bad. One of the most meaningless things is to judge someone by the look. Everyone has a right to wear what he or she wants. Our clothes is a way to express ourselves and there is nothing bad if someone's outfit is differ from mine or if I don't like it. After all, it's not my business, it's not my outfit. That person's look won't change anything in my own life, won't make any difference for me.
My look is important for me. I like to choose clothes according to my mood, clothes in which I feel the most comfortable in exact day. I feel myself better when I'm wearing good clothes, so I try to choose them carefully. My outfit makes me feel the certain way. For some other people it's different. many of people don't really care how do they look and it's totally fine with me. The most important thing is the personality, not the look.
Of course that looks doesn’t matter but very often you can see what the type of person you are dealing with.
Looking at the sentence above you can probably see that I’m in fact judgmental. Although I don’t judge people on their looks. I judge them mostly by the way they speak and behave.
Why? I don’t really know why but I just am.
I think judging people makes us kinda awful but not really, we are only humans and judging people is justified evolutionarily. Because of judging people we can know who or what to avoid.
Yes, I agree that look aren't everything, but we as a people often judge others by their looks. I think it can be caused by our main way to contact with world is through our eyes. Our whole life is based on our judgement on everything, do we like it or not, it depends on the way we are interacting with it as we speak about objects right now, but when we change to our perception of other people, we as a species must have a first impression of someone and if we are talking about people we are passing on a pavement, the only way to do it is by it's look and the same situation is when we meet someone for first time. We don't know anything about him so our first impression is his look. Problem is when someone is making from this first impression his final thought about someone and some people are doing this. I don't know why, it's probably because they are think of themselves as superior to others.
I agree that looks aren't everything, but do not kid yourself - judging by look is a natural thing. I often judge people by look, because (in most cases of course) - look tells about person. However I always abstain of making final judge about person until few small talks. I don't think so that judging people based on look makes us awful. It's a natural thing like I said before. Somebody's look isn't the most important thing for me, but still - important.
Vyvyan said…
Looks aren't everything. I don't judge someone because of their look. Personality is more important to me. But I judge someone if we talk about intelligence or hobby's - if it fits my 'needs' or just I have good conversations with other person, I can give that person 10/10 :)
I think it's not awful if we are focused on more areas than just looks. Because someone can be 'ugly' outside and be beautiful inside. Saying that someone is ugly, looking on outside layer only it's awful. Not judging the whole person.
I want to feel good in my body so it's important to me to look good. But I don't look on others.
KamilG said…
I agree with statement presented in article. Appearance isn't everything and everyone knows it perfectly.
We should judge others based on deeds, character, but an appearance is important as well.
It helps us to get attention of other people allowing us to show them later our quintessence - character.
There is even such a famous saying: "Our look is a reflection of our character".
1) Looks are not everything but it is very important and I think everyone should take that into strong consideration.
2) Yes, but not only look - for me it is very important how person reacts on different aspects/situations. Body language can tell you a lot of things about the person. I could never hire a filthy person because most of staff won't like to work with him and he would look bad for the company.
3) It doesn't make us awful - look, touch, feel are our basis instincts - we have to learn to listen to them, they are mostly telling us the truth.
Magdalena Popek said…
Of course we judge people by their looks. It is the very first thing we know about a person. Nicely dressed person, as mentioned, will earn our trust more easily than a person who definitely does not care about the look. But how much will this opinion influence our behaviour towards that person is something completely different.
In my opinion judging people by looks is meant to keep us safe. We won't approach a person that looks "unsafe" for us. Even though it may be the nicest person ever - if we don't know him or her, we won't come close.
I create the very first opinion about someone based on their looks. But this opinion is just an opinion on their looks. A person's behaviour can change it completely. I try not to say "I don't like him/her" just based on their looks. I always try to get to know them or otherwise I just say "I have no opinion, I don't know him/her"
Unknown said…
Agree with you, guys. Everybody judges, even automatically.

It is not bad, cause if you are smart enough, you can get the necessary information, analyzing the person's look. I am not talking about the qualities that we got from Mother Nature, but about the haircut, clothes, if the person is clean and neat.
And there is a big difference between "judge" and "condemn". I can my some conclusions, but that doesn't mean I will think the person is bad and unworthy.
First impression is mostly made by the way you look. It is not everything but it gives you a big advantage among others in many aspects of life. I personally try not to judge people before I talk with them, even then I give them a second chance, because not everyone is good at first impressions (like me). If someone value looks, this desn't make him awful, she/he can have many good character traits. Nothig last forever, your look will disappear after time, and after death people won't mention your look but
achievements and good personallity traits, and even if people will mention your look, that makes it just sad.
Unknown said…
"Fine feathers make fine birds" it is undeniable truth. Personally, I try to figure out person's way of thinking first rather than judge on the looks.
Unknown said…
People jugding other people by there first met and on how people behave on this met and judge them by this first met on next meeting.
This is our humanity and i think it will be very hard to change it. Also other people force us to think about other people like thet want but we have to oppose it.
Bartosz Łyżwa said…
in my opinion we're jugding people because of our nature, we like talking about others and finding our common characteristics or our differences. I don't see anything wrong in judging but there is one kind of "judges". It's the type o people who are talking about outhers imperfections but... in fact those judges have many complexes and they are tying to hide it :)
Unknown said…
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said…
Do you agree that looks aren’t everything?
I totally agree but before you know somebody, you look those person and clothes express ourselves.
I won't judge someone just because of the way he/she looks like.
Do you think judging people (especially based on looks) makes us awful? - Yes it's bad behavior.
For me it's very important, I care about my body, clothes, perfumes and whole "image".

Popular posts from this blog

Week 1 (09-15.03) VOD

http://www.vod-consulting.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/1.jpg

Week 11 [03-09.06.2019] The problem with ecological cars emission in UK

The problem with ecological cars emission in UK Since the adoption of the European Emission Allowance Directive in the European Parliament, all car makers have tried to submit. Since 1992, the Euro I standard has been in force, which limited the emission of carbon monoxide to the atmosphere. The Euro VI standard currently applies, which limits the series of exhaust gases. These include: hydrocarbons, nitrogen and carbon oxides, and dust.   The most significant change was brought by the Euro IV standard. For the first time it introduced the limitation of nitrogen oxides, which are responsible for the harmful compounds of smog.   What is smog?   Smog consists of sulfur oxides, nitrogen and carbon. In addition, solid substances such as suspended dust (PM). Dust suspend in atmospheric aerosols may be in liquid and solid form. These can be particles of sea salt, clouds from the Sahara and artificial compounds made by people. These compounds often come fr

Week 4 [06-12.11.2017] This is what happens when you reply to spam email.

James Veitch is a British comedian. In today’s Ted Talk James with characteristic for himself a sense of humor shows how he deals with spam emails and why responding to junk messages may be sometimes dangerous. Questions: What do you think about James’s  way of dealing with spam? Why are junk messages legal, even though it sometimes may be a fraud? Dou you have a problem with spam? How do you deal with with it?