Skip to main content

Week 6 [20-26.11.17] Do you even hear what you hear?

In this TED-talk Julian Treasure talks about various sounds, their affect on us and how brains unconsciously process sound inputs. He also speaks about the correlation between the sounds frequency and their impact on us and the different aspects in which sounds have an affect on us. He even states an interesting theory about working in open spaces.

I really enjoyed this TED-talk and believe most of you will too.



Questions:
Did you ever think about the influence various sounds have on you?
Do you work in an open-space? If so, do you think it has an impact in your productivity?
Is the type of music you’re listening affecting the way you drive?
You just heard the Nokia ringtone in the TED-talk. Does your brain recognize it as a positive or negative sound?

Comments

There are situation where sounds might motivate me and other times sounds may make me to see red. So, to give some example of sounds that works good on me:
- I love to listen classical music, especially piano sounds, when I'm reading at the public places like public transport. It surly makes me more focused on what I'm reading.
- While browsing web or doing something that does not require using brain, I usually listen to rock music and sometimes rap music.
- When it comes to coding I'm very often listing to electronic beats, it also allows me to be more focused (artist which I may recommend to listen during coding is called Nujabes).
As I said before there are situations when sounds may have bad effect on me, for example:
- No matter how situations look like, I hate when someone is sniffing.
- When I'm trying to focus and there is some music playing that contains words.

I do work at the "open-space". I don't think that this affect my productivity. If I really need to be alone, I just put my headphones on and play some music I want. I know some people that love to work with some "noise" around and sometimes they go to café - it allows them to work better.
I do not think that music affects the way I'm driving. Of course when I'm listing to radio and they air something I really do not like it may make me a little angrier, but come on I always can change to other station.
I find Nokia ring tone very neutral to me. I do not have reasons to hate it or to love it. Best way to start hating some sound is to make it your clock alarm - works perfectly.
Anonymous said…
I think about sounds almost every time I travel by train. I love to read while travelling and I've noticed I can't focus when someone near me is talking. Sometimes I'd like to kill those people. I hate them especially when someone is talking by phone. I mean - really? Why won't you talk at home guys? Oh god I can't stand them!
Luckily I work at home so I have a huge comfort of working place and I can focus easily.
I think type of music affects everyone. I love listening to music while driving and I've noticed fast music makes me drive faster and slow music makes me relaxed on my way.
I think Nokia ringtone is rather positive sound for me.
Unknown said…
Yes. I often think about it. I’m pretty sure that various sounds do have impact on me. I’m experiencing it every day. I like different kinds of music and I chose which one to listen depending on my mood, activity I’m doing, emotion and many different aspects. One song can make me focused to do programming while the other one makes me more focused when I’m driving a car. Also there are various types of songs to drive with and some of them keep me calm whilst others make me the king of road. I work in open-space but there are only 10 people so there are some noises and sounds but they are necessary to kill unnecessary silence. Nokia ringtone is a sound which can’t turn on an feelings in me.
Unknown said…
Yes, people on their phones can be very annoying. I always find it funny when a 15 minute long monolog on the phone ends with "OK, I'm getting off the train/bus, I'll be at your place in 5 minutes!". Do they still have things to talk about when they meet?
Unknown said…
The ambient noise works positively for me as well. In high school I used to go to cafe's to study, and the same goes for the university because I get more focused. I can also recommend an app for that, that I sometimes use at home - Coffitivity - which is especially useful when there are any distracting noises outside my flat, e.g. a dog barking or some construction work being done.
Unknown said…
What kind of music makes you go all Fast&Furious behind the wheel? :)
I often think about the influence of sounds in my life and I like learning new things about this influence. I often observe my reaction to some sounds and I love that I can use my observations results to manipulate my mood by listening to certain type of music.
I do work on open-space and I got used to the noise of it. But when I stay in work for a little bit longer and everyone from open-space have left I'm doing everything much more faster.
I love listening to the slow and chilling music while driving because most of the time I'm rather slow-speed driver who chills behind the wheel. And the music helps me with chilling.
My brains has recognised the nokia's ringtone as a neutral sound.
Unknown said…
I thought about the infuence of various sounds as long as I really feel that they affect me.
There are sounds that annoys me and I can't focus, I can even get angry because it is teasing me - for example sounds of nature. For many people those sounds are neutral or reassuring, but for me it is tiresome and aching (literally!)
I'm not working in an open space, but I work in room with many people (there are 12 people in a room) and I can tell that it affects me. When everyone is working and there is quiet it is quiet, but when someone have to comunicate, ask questions or they even chat a little it is hard to stay focused - many sounds, words, you don't know what is importnat for you, what was directed to you - so you're on a watch.
Unknown said…
Of course sounds influence me. In the past I really liked working in total silence.Today I like it when something plays very quietly. I often turn the TV on only because I want to hear something. But I noticed that programs like "Trudne Sprawy" influence me in a negative way.
Type of music you listen to has influence on how you drive. Maybe it is strange but when I listen to heavy rock music, I feel sleepy. But with electro/hip-hop music it is the opposite.
Unknown said…
Yes, I think about the influence of various sounds on me every day and it happens mostly at the time when some strong and massive sound wave hits me. I do work in an open-space area, but I don't find it distractive nor decreasing my productivity. I need some sound, talks or quiet music to concentrate, I really can't stand full silence around me. I also take headphones with me to work, therefore I can mute some loud talks of my workmates. I don't drive too much, so I don't really have an opinion about fourth question. Nokia ringtone brings positive vibes in my opinion, although the company itself isn't recognized well for me. Nevertheless, sound is positive.
Patryk Pohnke said…
Yes, music has huge impact on most people minds.
I have desk near the hall which sometimes is used by people and I don't really mind that. At some point people talking nearby become irritating but that's not common thing.
Do you work in an open-space? If so, do you think it has an impact in your productivity?
The volume level of the music is affecting me more than the type of the music.
For me it is positive sound.
Yes, i think that everyone of us has some kind of sounds that they hate and they're making them weird. For example my most hated sound is scratching the nails on blackboard. I can't even think about it because it makes me feel uncomfortable.
I'm working in an open-space and i think it's good for me and my productivity. You can feel better because of the free space around you.
I think that the music you're listening to is affecting the way you drive but only a little.
I recognize Nokia's rightbone rather positive, i cannot say why, but it makes me feel relaxed.
Unknown said…
Interesting TED talk, made me realize how some of our reactions are due to surrounding sounds/noise.
Personally I pick on annoying sounds instantly and just can't stand certain kinds of it, high pitch, specific frequency. If a persons voice annoys me I will avoid that person, if someone sqeaks with a chair I will look around for the source, if a door someone closed behind didn't "click" properly I will hear/notice from 5 meters which I often do at work even though being occupied/concetrated on the work. This TED talk made me more aware of that and that helps with being less annoyed with sounds.
At work there is kinda open-space and certain days it's really hard to concentrate with a lot of fuss going around but as mentioned in the video headphones can save the day! As for kind of music affecting the way I drive, of course it does ;) Powerful, kicking, heavy metal, rock kind certainly makes me little more "energetic" as a driver and soothing, tuned makes me a granny driver.
Everyone know Nokia ringtone, in the context of the video it surprised me that "oh yeah, I know that sound and instantly I know that brand, that product, etc". I recognized it in a positive way but given that it's quite a result of fine marketing I don't know how to feel about it.
Yevhen Shymko said…
I love music! Countless times music helped me to motivate my self to do something I knew I need to do but can't help myself. It help when you just falling asleep while walking just put your headphones on with max speed and rock music and there is much less chance of falling asleep. Even when you feel upset and don't want to interact with outside world it helps you to forget about your problems and just enjoy the music. I think our life would be much worst without the music.
I bet it’s soundtrack from Fast&Furious :)
I guess I think about with what I associate given sound more than how it influences me. For example I have a skylight in my room and it makes sound of rain very noticeable especially when I study. That’s why when I really need to focus I go to www.rainymood.com. I work in an open space at noise doesn’t really bother me. People looking at my screen bother me.
Foodocado said…
I am quite sure the various sounds have impact on us. I work in the rooms of 2-3 people. I like working like that, it's quite silent. I can focus on my work and nothing is interrupting me. I don't know if I would be able to work in an open-space. For sure, some day I will have opportunity to check it out. I like various types of music. It depends what mood i have and what activity i do. When I drive, I enoy listening to calm music. It makes me relaxed and I am able to focus on driving the car.
Vladlen Kyselov said…
I am absolutely sure that sounds are making an impact on us. I prefer to work without unnecessary sounds that can distract me or reduce my will or productivity of working. I am trying not to listen to music because now it is hard for me to tell which kind of music can help a human to concentrate on work that he is currently doing. I prefer to listen different kind music in brakes before and after work depending on what I am going to do in next several hours. For example before going to sleep I am listening to some chill music to make my mind relax from everyday problems and tasks that I am focused on.
Unknown said…
I find it very interesting how different people's experience with working in an open space is and that it is about 50/50 for those who can't focus as good in such environment and the ones that focus even better having some background noise. I am much more productive when I have some ambient noise around me and would not be able to work as efficiently when the office was empty...
Unknown said…
Oh yes, I can relate to the lack of door-clicking sound. It annoys me as well. As well as non-lined up monitors on a desk. Or unorganised cables under the desk. Along with many other things people do or don't do.
Unknown said…
I actually know people who either don't like or don't care about music at all. It is hard to comprehend because on the affect it has on most people depending on the music type - as you wrote.
Unknown said…
Maybe you should consider getting a polarised screen filter and matching polarised glasses? This way you won't have to care about these people anymore!
Unknown said…
I found that the music you listen to while driving actually has very various impact from person to person. There are people who are affected very little by the type of music and volume, and there are people on whom the impact is enormous. You seem to be one of the lucky ones.
Sure, various sounds, have influence on us. It is easy to get distract by sounds, for example by hearing something it could bring some memories from the past or just disturb. I have worked in open-space, at begining it was hard to focus on my tasks, but in the course of time I learned to be focused enough to work. I prefer to drive listening to classical or pop/rock music. The Nokia sound brings good memories when I was younger.
Marcin Górski said…
I think that sound are making an impact on us. I love silence when I have to be more productively.
I'm working in open-space but people from my team are very quiet. Everyone has headphones and that is a key for working in open-space. When we want to talk about something and make a break, we are going to kitchen.
When I drive, I like listening hip-hop music.
In think that Nokia ringtone is positive for me, nothing more :)
At first i used to work in small private office and there i never had problem with noises created by others but now while im working in some bigger open-space if i have some really important and hard task i need some barrer so i put on my headphones. Same stuff wile im using pupblic transport, i love to read with some "epic music" in my ears. It helps me to drown in plot even more.

Going back to first question, sure. There are some noises like scratching, slurping or constant coughing drives me crazy.

I think different kinds of music does not affect our driving style but usually we are playing type that suits our mood and that goes together with our driving style.
Unknown said…
I often think about the influence of various sounds on my activities and I always try to adjust sounds that surround me to the task I have to accomplish, e.g.: by carefully choosing the place I work on this task. Even though I work in quiet rooms instead of noisy open plan office, other sounds can easy reduce my productivity e.g.: someone being on the phone next to me. Nokia ringtone does not make me feel neither better nor worse, it is just tone that sounds familiar to me and make me imagine good old Nokia cell phone.
Unknown said…
The topic is very interesting. And I agree with the speaker, the sound has a huge impact on us. I notice my mood depend on music. For instance, if I listen to something active and fast, I walk faster. Or I have more energy when working out and listening to suitable music. But it doesn't work well when I'm studying and have to concentrate on something. Even quiet and calm music will distract me in this case.
And also sound making is very interesting. Some days ago I saw the video about how the sound for a short film was made. It was so funny. There was a guy who was rubbing a balloon in front of the microphone.
Vyvyan said…
I don't work in an open-space but in our room are... eight, nine people (sometimes more if someone have problem). Sometimes becomes very noisy but then I just using headphones which drown out sounds that irritates me.

The type of music I'm listening is affecting the most of things I'm doing. Even effects on my mood but I think it's naturally.

Em... About Nokia ringtone... It's positive for me I think. It's just a good, old ringtone.
Unknown said…
Did you ever think about the influence various sounds have on you?
Yes, especially when I try to relax in my home and some neighbor start to renovate his apartment.
Do you work in an open-space? If so, do you think it has an impact in your productivity?
Yes I work in the open space and I agree with the TED talker, there is a big impact on a productivity, but in other hand open-space integrate people who work on the same project and that could increase productivity of all team.
Is the type of music you’re listening affecting the way you drive?
Yes I am less angry when I stay in a traffic jam. In other cases has less impact.
You just heard the Nokia ringtone in the TED-talk. Does your brain recognize it as a positive or negative sound?
Positive, only sounds that I have set on my alarm clock are recognized as negative by my brain.
Unknown said…
Haha, exactly!
How can they function like this? Living a pure chaos, ridiculous. Everything should be well organized and work like a clock ;)
Unknown said…
I thought about influence that some sounds have on me. For example noisy neighbours have impact on us. Also car horns certainly have impact on us. I worked in open space. Some people were migrating to other spaces, because in their space was too noisy. I think it can affect productivity very much. Open space has also advantages. It increases productivity by giving a nice atmosphere between employees. Music which I listen doesn't affect my driving.
Zygmunt Z said…
Of course that various sounds have influence on me and on my process of working. It can be anything – from car horns, dogs barking, children crying or loud music in your neighbour’s flat. Last company that I worked for had a system of open-spaces and it really had an impact on my productivity. It was quiet and by looking at my coworkers I had the feeling that I also have to do something. Lastly, I have to admit that the type of music and period of day affects my driving. I like every music genre but my favourite one – rock music, can cause that I can “slightly” exceed the speed limit.
I find music to have major impact on my mood. Every day I listen to music on my way to work and I find myself agitated, even uncomfortable when deprived of the ability to do so. I have also found various kinds of music to have a relaxing effect when listened to in the evening, or even an energizing effect, when listened to in the morning when I'm still drowsy.

The most powerful application of music however, I'd say is the its proper use in cinema. A good music, properly used can greatly improve a mediocre movie, and make a good movie a great one. A good example of the power of music in that respect in the first Twilight movie. Not only did it have an excellent soundtrack, they have expertly used it to create a proper mood for the movie, in effect making it quite an enjoyable experience. The second part however forewent the music, and it fell on its face, from a cliff, in a burning car.

I have no doubt that trying to work in noisy environment would have a destructive effect on one's ability to concentrate and solve mental tasks. I live next to an airport, so I can personally attest to the disruptive effect such noise has on your performance.
Unknown said…
I was working with 8 people in my room. We were programming and everyone had headsets. I dont like when someone is talking or when I hear anything from outside. Type of music is definitly affecting me, if it is fast then I am driving faster, if its happy then I am singing, if its sad I am driving with bad mood. It's quite interesting. If you are asking about NOKIA ringfone I would say that its positive for me.
Magdalena Popek said…
I know various sounds have influence on us. When I hear my co-worker's ringtone (Nokia) my heart rate raises quickly because I had the same ringtone when I was working in England and a phonecall could mean I will get a new job, so I rushed to the phone everytime I heard it. I also avoid some clothes shops due to horrible music inside.
I work in an open-space and usually the noise doesn't bother me. But sometimes few people would meet in a corridor, start laughing, talking. That's horrible.
When I heard the ringtone my heart sped up a bit. Because of the reason I described above :P
Marcin Mróz said…
I do not work in open-space and I'm really happy about it. There are 6 persons in my room and usually it's quiet and you can concentrate on your work. Of course sometimes some people come in to ask for help or discuss something, but as far as this isn't permanent, it doesn't bother me so much. I always listen to music in the car, but I don't think that it affects the way I'm driving. I believe that if music affects someone while he/she is driving, he/she has got some serious problem. ;)
Unknown said…
Of course it makes an impact on us.
When I’m chilling at home, I like to listen to some calm music - Chill Radio 24/7 on YouTube, Casey’s Neistat playlist on Spotify, etc. It’s just music without any words.
When I need some energy, I’m listening to metal or rap.
I was working in groups of 4 and it was great, because of silence. When you want to talk - you can talk, but when you’re working, you can focus and nobody is interrupting you.
Yes, music is affecting my way of driving a lot.
Nokia ringtone is neutral to me. It’s just a ringtone. As Andrzej Nieswiadomski said: „Best way to start hating some sound is to make it your clock alarm”.
I totally agree with him.
Unknown said…
Total time played: 5 weeks 1d 12:58:54 for like one year?
Almost every day i go sleep with music turned on like: space ambient or just plain ambient. I can't fall asleep while music is too "harsh". Driving a car: music from phone turned on. Going by public transport, music from phone. It is half of my life. Visuals without sound does nothing. I like best in summer to open my windows, turn on some space ambient at like 2-3 am, sit on balcony with smoke and watch stars. One of the best things for me. Goosebumps guaranteed with nice feeling flowing through my entire body. I think i am like Arnold Schwarzenegger while doing a workout:"When i hit that peak when working out, i feel like cumming:)" but with music.
Unknown said…
Unfortunately I'm the type of a person that can't focus when something or someone makes any noises. I can't also learn/work while listening to music. I wish I could change that but nothing has worked.
I've worked once in an open-space. Luckily it was quiet there and I could focus. If it weren't I would probably use noise plugs to keep my productivity on the same level.
Yes, music affects the way I drive. Mostly I listen to peaceful music in my car, because it calms me down and the way to home is more pleasant. Only at night I prefer to listen something faster ;)
My brain recognised Nokia ringtone as a positive sound. It's because Nokia was my first mobile phone and I really enjoyed it.
Unknown said…
What an awesome presentation and interesting TED-talk:)
Music has a huuuge influence on me, I love music, I can't live without music, it can make me happy or sad in a moment. The use of the sounds and music in cinema is an art, because it affects our feelings and emotions. They use it in advertising to catch our attention...
When I am forced to work in an open space, like in our PJATK canteen, for example, I usually listen to Sigur Ros, their music isolates me from the sounds and noises around and it allows to concentrate. It can also be something like Trentemoller or Apparat. I also need these guys when I travel on a night train and must separate from the sounds to fall asleep.
When I drive music is essential. Sometimes I can just leave my home at night to drive while listening to the music alone. And of course music does affect my driving style. The best ride soundtrack for me is Limp Bizkit - Rolling (that version with DMX) :D
That Nokia sound is pleasant and a little bit nostalgic. I used to own Nokia when I was a teen. I guess, each of us remember these crazy years of life:)
I'm listening to music every time I'm doing something productive, even right now Aerosmith is playing in the background :).

It makes every work much more enjoyable, I can't imagine myself just sitting here in the silence writing code or text, listening to my own click clocks as I push buttons on my mechanical keyboard.

Music type doesn't really matter for me as I can listen to almost any genre, and music in this case is always supporting factor, which means I do not focus on it in particular, it's just here in the background keeping my creative brain side happy while my logical one can focus on given task being done :).
I believe that different music can affect people differently. Depending on the volume and the desired effect it can help, but also distract the attention. I do not like working in open space because it is hard to focus. Sometimes you can focus on work using headphones and listen to your own music, unfortunately this is not a frequent privilege. When I have to concentrate I like to listen to music without text like deep house.
Tomasz Morawski said…
Sound has quite big influence in my life but to be honest, most of the sounds I pay attention to (besides music) are distractful. The only positive sound I can remember is me pressing keys on my keyboard :)
I don't work in open space but nevertheless my office tends to be quite noisy. Usually it's not a big problem for me but if I need to focus really hard, I put my headphones on so it's not a big deal.
I don't think the music I listen to while driving has some effect on me. I'm a daydreamer type, so I don't even care.
I used to have Nokia phone and used Nokia tune for a long time in my childhood, so I usually involuntarily look for my phone, even though I don't have Nokia since high school or so.
Did you ever think about the influence various sounds have on you?
Of course especially in my work when I need to focus a headphones is a must or everyone else has to be quiet for a while in the office. Also try to go to a supermarket and when children are shouting you will go mad especially during Christmas period it is too loud.

Do you work in an open-space? If so, do you think it has an impact in your productivity?

Is the type of music you’re listening affecting the way you drive?
Hmmmm there is two songs I'm banned from listening in the car. Darude - Sandstorm or Safri Duo - Played-A-Live. On the motobike the record was around 300kmh in the car around 250kmh on the autobahn.

You just heard the Nokia ringtone in the TED-talk. Does your brain recognize it as a positive or negative sound?
I know the sound but completely does not affect me. I was a Siemens fan from the start :)
Unknown said…
Good one! I know about construction sounds, I lived in one apartment when they started building the Q22 building in the city center on the plot next to me. I moved, and they started to build an apartment building next door. I am now afraid of moving because most likely I'll end up next to another construction site...
Unknown said…
If you were that concerned about loud music you would not throw parties at your place all the time! :D
Unknown said…
Oh yes, I remember the days when I was setting songs as alarms. I hate them to this day...
Unknown said…
Do you mean that your mechanical switches are not enjoyable enough? :D
Unknown said…
Oh yes, the Nokia tune is deeply engraved in our brains now...
Unknown said…
I quite often do my groceries in the night or just order them online to avoid all the supermarket craziness. I hate standing in lines, children screams and all the other madness. Going to Tesco at 2am on the other hand can even be a bit relaxing :)

Popular posts from this blog

Week 1 (09-15.03) VOD

http://www.vod-consulting.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/1.jpg

Week 11 [03-09.06.2019] The problem with ecological cars emission in UK

The problem with ecological cars emission in UK Since the adoption of the European Emission Allowance Directive in the European Parliament, all car makers have tried to submit. Since 1992, the Euro I standard has been in force, which limited the emission of carbon monoxide to the atmosphere. The Euro VI standard currently applies, which limits the series of exhaust gases. These include: hydrocarbons, nitrogen and carbon oxides, and dust.   The most significant change was brought by the Euro IV standard. For the first time it introduced the limitation of nitrogen oxides, which are responsible for the harmful compounds of smog.   What is smog?   Smog consists of sulfur oxides, nitrogen and carbon. In addition, solid substances such as suspended dust (PM). Dust suspend in atmospheric aerosols may be in liquid and solid form. These can be particles of sea salt, clouds from the Sahara and artificial compounds made by people. These compounds often come fr

Week 4 [06-12.11.2017] This is what happens when you reply to spam email.

James Veitch is a British comedian. In today’s Ted Talk James with characteristic for himself a sense of humor shows how he deals with spam emails and why responding to junk messages may be sometimes dangerous. Questions: What do you think about James’s  way of dealing with spam? Why are junk messages legal, even though it sometimes may be a fraud? Dou you have a problem with spam? How do you deal with with it?