Skip to main content

Week 12 (08.06 - 14.06) FGM – the pain of purity

A couple days ago I came across an article that made me stop and think about the importance of this subject. It was only on May 5th that Nigeria has officially passed a law making female genital mutilation (FGM) illegal. This cruel ritual is practiced mostly in 27 African countries but also in Yemen, Iraqi Kurdistan and even some parts of Asia. It touches girls of all ages, from newborns to teenagers. There three types of female circumcision, depending on its severity. The most general definition accepted by WHO, UNICEF and UNFPA in 1997, states that FGM is the partial or total removal of the external female genitalia or other injury to the female genital organs for non-medical reasons. In most cases, the procedure is performed by other women with no anesthesia in awful, non-sterile conditions. It is not uncommon to use dirty, rusty razor blades and wooden needles for stitching and closing the wound.  There are no known medical benefits of this procedure while complications and side effects can be deadly. Women can experience notorious infections, chronic pain, bleeding, infertility and even death around the time of the ritual or childbirth. This ritual is deeply rooted in the cultures where it occurs. It aims to gain control over girls’ sexuality and secure her purity for the husband. Mothers often force their daughters to undergo this procedure in fear that if someone will discover that the girl is uncut the family will face persecution and social exclusion.


Historical evidence of female circumcision can be found in documents dating as far back as ancient Egypt, however there has been no physical signs on discovered mummies. What shocked me while researching this subject, was the fact that even in 19th century Europe and United States, female circumcision was a method for curing insanity, nymphomania and hysteria. Luckily, with the growth of opposition public awareness was raised and different countries begun taking legal actions to prevent FGM. However, this painful subject is still very new in terms of media coverage and data collection. The first survey that contained questions touching this matter was conducted in northern Sudan in the years 1989 and 1990.


Currently it is estimated that there are 125 million girls and women who have survived this procedure. Since FGM has been under legal regulations there is a decrease in performed FGM. The biggest drop has been noted in countries with lower prevalence and unfortunately those which high prevalence still show alarmingly high popularity. It is visible that all work done by various governments and organizations is bringing positive effects, however there is still much to be done to ensure the safety of women around the world.

In the end, I want to show you a short clip from the movie “Desert Flower”, describing the story of a girl who escaped to London from Somalia and became a fashion model. This allowed her to start fighting with the terrifying practice that she has experienced herself and help others.


Sources:

Comments

This is the first time I read about the FHM and I feel shocked. I heard many times about this in context of man but never in context of women. I understand the importance of religion tradition, but I see absolutely no sense in removing and part of human body and explaining it as the ritual made for God. Unfortunately, it seems to me that the official recognition of this ritual as illegal will not stop many peoples from performing the procedure. Recently I watched reportage about Syria where issue of underage married women is illegal. Despite the ban families still sell 12 and 13 years old girls in exchange for a piece of the field. The cases given to the court are rejected due to bribery judges. It seems to me that in the same way the trial will be held on FGM.
Julia Osiak said…
For sure introducing laws against FGM will not improve women's situation overnight, but statistics already show decreasing numbers in some regions. As people will become more aware, more organisations will take action.
Unknown said…
I've heard about FHM many times and I've also heard about the model that is an activist for that case. In my opinion it's a terrible practice and it's terrifying that it's still common in many parts of Africa. I don't understand the cultural pressure. If the consequences of such a "procedure" are so severe and obvious. The death rate is so high that I just can't imagine someone willingly putting their child up for such a horrid torture.

I'm against any forced mutilation of the body both female and male. So I'm also against circumcision and I don't understand why it is still acceptable in western culture to cut off a part of a person's (child's) body without their consent. Regardless if it's a religious reason or not (I was surprised that circumcision is so popular in United States among not religious people as a cosmetic procedure) it's not acceptable to make a decision like that for anybody.

Here is a funny and informative video about circumcision: http://www.collegehumor.com/video/6966989/the-real-reason-youre-circumcised
Unknown said…
It is very important and difficult topic. It is frightening how much these women must suffer. These procedures have a take place in awful conditions, inhumane. In my opinion this ritual is totally inhume and stupid. Women are treated like slaves, animals, may be even worse that animals. I have never before heard about it was a method for curing insanity, nymphomania and hysteria. It is interesting but too invasive in my opinion. Unfortunately I haven’t read “Desert flower” and I haven’t watched this film, but I will do it. I have heard the story about Waris Dirie. It is amazing. It is great that people like Waris exist and they want to help other people.
This comment has been removed by the author.
Julia I agree with you. Laws against FGM will not change women's situation soon. Unfortunately, FGM is a part of tradition and culture of those countries which can't be bannend or eraced succesfully only because of the new law. Education is the key to solve FGM problem.
Julia Osiak said…
You are right, the law itself will not do much good if people will not be more aware of the consequences of this procedure.
What do you think about the opinion of some anthropologists, that the way in which FGM is being fought with currently, creates an effect of dehumanization of those that perform this ritual (as the cultural aspect is not taken into consideration) and it does not help in spreading women's equality?
Julia Osiak said…
If I may correct you, it is not FHM but FGM. Maybe it was just a typo? :p

I knew that circumcision is quite popular in the States, but I was surprised to find statistics stating that in 2005, 56% of male newborns had the procedure before release from the hospital. There is also quite a lot of teenage boys who decide themselves to undergo this procedure.
Unknown said…
I'm quite shocked. I've heard about this ritual practice, but I wasn't aware it is so widespread. In my opinion no one should be allowed to mutilate a person's body in such a way. Not only it is disgusting, but also life-threatening for the „patient”. I find it terrifying that people are so blinded by cultural or religious tenets that they allow to risk their children's lives. And for what? For some absolutely dumb reason.

Like Cezary, I'm afraid that the official ban on FGM isn't enough to stop this procedure from happening. Many people will avoid this new law. But it's a good start I think.
Unknown said…
Yes, it was a typo, sorry about that :)
Julia Osiak said…
Waris Dirie is a brave and strong woman. Thanks to her openness more people have heard about this problem. If you get the chance, you definitely should watch her story.
Unknown said…
Many times I read about other rituals in Africa, but I've never heard of this ritual and I'm shocked. Religious traditions are important in the life of every believer, however, in my opinion, total stupidity is harming their health.
Very good it is the authority in Nigeria sees these problems and trying to take steps to reduce the scales of FGM. Perhaps the official prohibit such actions will not solve the problem completely, but it certainly will increase awareness of the people in this area.
Michal Kulesza said…
First I've heard about this ritual in Deserf Flower movie, however I thought it's dead - it's so crucial that I thought noone practices it.

I also think that banning it won't help - because in Africa there will be people that will still believe in it. But it's still a good step to educate people, that it does harm.
I've also heard that this ritual prevents women from having pleasure from sex (or minimalizes it).
Julia Osiak said…
I would not go as far as saying that their reason is dumb or stupid. It is such a strong part of their religion and tradition that they do not question its logic. Also the potential violence against the family in case of not performing this ritual is so high that people do it out of fear of being ostracized or to give the girls 'a chance for finding a husband and living a "normal" life' according to their standards.
Julia Osiak said…
You're right, apart from various threats to woman's health and even life, removing part of her genitals does lead to taking away from her the sexual pleasure. In case of the most invasive type of circumcision, not only will the woman have no pleasure from sex, it will most likely be very painful and sometime can lead to injuries.
Julia Osiak said…
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said…
I’m aware that there is a FGM problem in the world It is awful that young female genital organs are injured without their permision. I’m glad that we live in Europe and it is not popular in our culture. However this custon is a part of culture and religion. Sometimes it is hard to say if it is a right or wrong custom. For us it can be something bad, but for them it can have a special meaning. I heard about that model and her story is really touching. It is incredible how strong and powerful she is.
Unknown said…
I've heard about FGM many times and every single time the situation was not getting better. Thanks people like this girl from video that survive and talk about this problem to the whole world, I think it is very important to spread the information about such subjects. However, I don't think that passing a law can change this situation, the root is much more deeper. It is about traditions, we should change people's minds and their understanding of such procedures. I agree with Katarzyna that education can help more than any laws.
Unknown said…
I have heard about this ritual quite long time ago, before the Desert Flower story, I have read it in a book about some other model from Somalia, that was struggling with this problem. I was quite young because I was about 14 years old and it really shocked me! I would never even thought that something so awful, so cruel is happening all the time, it sounds like something that could have been done in medieval, not XXI century! That's really good that someone is doing anything to help that women, because the cruelty and pointless of doing this is so extreme that I cannot even explain what is a point of doing this....?! Craziness!
Unknown said…
These african girls goes through so much pain. I remember autobiography of Waris Dirie was a great bestseller couple years ago. Her story started a discussion about female circumcision, thanks to it, we have consciousness of these practices. FGM reminds me another rite, chinese foot binding (thankfully, it began to die out in 20th century). Similar to FGM, women were forced and renouncement directed to social exclusion. That's horrible - we can see adaptating women to the culture "standards" is the global problem.
Julia Osiak said…
I'm glad that some of you have already heard about this. Unfortunatelly this is not the only cruel ritual performed on women. All over the world there are many other procedures that give me shivers. Although if you think about it, the so popular breast enhancement isn't much better, 'luckily' it's the woman's decision to undergo this operation.
Mateusz Frycie said…
FGM is a big problem in Muslim communities in African countries. But this is not only the problem of this part of the world. We are becoming a global village, each and every year thousands of immigrants from Africa arrive into European countries. They bring here their culture, religion and rituals. We should be aware of this fact and do all we can to stop customs that are barbarian and hurt other human beings.
Unknown said…
Hard to believe that we are living in 21st century. Such a cruelity is pointless and i think it should be forbidden, hunt and punish by all goverments
Unknown said…
I will watch it. I want to do it so I can promise you that I will do it. Yes, she is a very brave and strong woman. Women like Waris should be more.
People who had anthropology classes with mgr Walentowicz probably heard the rule about not judging other cultures or consider them worse than ours. However, I really have troubles with that whenever I hear about things like mutilating parts of bodies for religious reasons. I think it's horrible and inhumane. It's good that it was banned in Nigeria - I know it will not solve the problem overnight, but it may help, as well as Waris Dirie's story being told.
I'd watched story of that model long time ago. There is not much to discuss about as case is clear, it should be stopped by all means necessary, which means law and its execution. There is not much to add.
Unknown said…
I've watched the whole 'desert flower' movie and I was really shocked that such events still take place. It's ridiculous that people believe that it saves the purity of girls, even when it costs their lives. I can't believe that purity is more important than human live. I feel such a pity when I hear about these helpless individuals that are subjected to circumcisions.
I took those clases and I remember the rule but I cannot judge something like this. Pointelss, painfull and for what? I agree, if we talk about it, see the problem maybe someday it will disapear.....
It is all just so wrong for me....Do you recommand the movie? Is it more about this problem or just the bio of the model?
We are so lucky to live in Europe....
If doing such things can have a special meaning for them then they are even worst, do you agree?
This is cruel and I don't know the reason for doing that, really. Women are free and doing such a thing is breaking their natural law for freedom and being healthy from the very beginning. Men or women circumcision is equally unnecessary and should be forbidden all over the world. That drives me crazy how human rights are violated everyday and how unimportant a single unit in society is...
Unknown said…
I have heard about this new law and I am very happy about it. I am not an activist and in fact I'm not even very interested, but the subject of FGM is kind of emotional for me. When I was little, I was reading practically everything and my book choices have never been censored by my parents. When I was about 12 I read a book "Desert Flower" by Waris Dirie, a Somali model and social activist. It was about Waris' life before the beginning of her career - she fled from her nomadic family after having been circumsized and promised as a wife for a much older man and she was running from her roots for a long time. It touches the problem of FGM and its consequences. This book was so shocking for me that hearing about FGM was bringing some strong emotions ever since. If you are interested in this subject I really recommend this book. The movie is based on this book, but I have never watched it.
This problem is very important, but there are hundreds of other problems that Africa has. It is not easy to just ban something, african people very often don't know what their rights are or just don't care...
Marcin Lyzwa said…
I have heard about FGM before but once again I'm very shocked and I still don't know why in the XXI century such things happens. For what ? In the name of some God ? It is absurd and sick... Maiming people for religion staggers the imagination.
Unfortunately ban won't change anything, only education can do it.
Unknown said…
I think that is a very important issue. I heard earlier about these practices. Unfortunately, in African culture this custom became popular. It's hard for me to believe that for some people "purity" of women is more important then her life.
I have watched the whole 'desert flower' movie and I was really shocked. I found out how much these practices are awful.
Unknown said…
I think that such procedures should be banned all over the world. Although I realize that they stem from some long-standing and deep-rooted traditions, I reckon that nobody deserves such treatment. Women suffer, a lot of them die, just because of some religious tenets that in my opinion have only negative aspects. I hope circumcision will be prohibited all over the world in the close future.
Unknown said…
I guess I must agree. It is hard to say for me about this problem .
I was aware of this problem for quite some time. It is truly horrible that in this day and age, such practices are common in some regions of the world. I highly recommend everyone to watch the mentioned movie in the article - “Desert Flower”. It does a pretty good job with showing the culture of regions that practice FGM and how big this problem is and its repercussions for women throughout their life.

Popular posts from this blog

Week 1 (09-15.03) VOD

http://www.vod-consulting.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/1.jpg

Week 11 [03-09.06.2019] The problem with ecological cars emission in UK

The problem with ecological cars emission in UK Since the adoption of the European Emission Allowance Directive in the European Parliament, all car makers have tried to submit. Since 1992, the Euro I standard has been in force, which limited the emission of carbon monoxide to the atmosphere. The Euro VI standard currently applies, which limits the series of exhaust gases. These include: hydrocarbons, nitrogen and carbon oxides, and dust.   The most significant change was brought by the Euro IV standard. For the first time it introduced the limitation of nitrogen oxides, which are responsible for the harmful compounds of smog.   What is smog?   Smog consists of sulfur oxides, nitrogen and carbon. In addition, solid substances such as suspended dust (PM). Dust suspend in atmospheric aerosols may be in liquid and solid form. These can be particles of sea salt, clouds from the Sahara and artificial compounds made by people. These compounds often come fr

Week 4 [06-12.11.2017] This is what happens when you reply to spam email.

James Veitch is a British comedian. In today’s Ted Talk James with characteristic for himself a sense of humor shows how he deals with spam emails and why responding to junk messages may be sometimes dangerous. Questions: What do you think about James’s  way of dealing with spam? Why are junk messages legal, even though it sometimes may be a fraud? Dou you have a problem with spam? How do you deal with with it?